up button

The truth behind
organ donation
& transplants

The truth behind organ donation & transplants

      OrganFacts.net  … Wait for the Lord; take courage and He will give strength to your heart; yes, wait for the Lord. (Psalm 27:14)

 © OrganFacts.net

… The truth behind organ donation & organ transplants


Dr David W Evans

Dr David W Evans , Retired Consultant in Cardiology, says: “Human organ transplantation is Wrong because it necessitates the abuse of the dying or harming the healthy. Doctors should not be involved in such things… I don’t know how any doctor can operate on his patient not for his good but knowingly to do him harm.” [more]


Dr David J Hill

Dr David J Hill , Retired consultant anaesthetist, says: “The Diagnosis of Death for Transplant Purposes has no international consensus and in the UK… depends upon testing only a few cubic centimetres of tissue in the brainstem for loss of function… Live organs can only come from living bodies. ” [more]


Dr Paul A Byrne

Dr Paul A Byrne , neonatalogist and pediatrician, says: “In order to be suitable for transplant, (heart, liver, lungs, kidneys and pancreas) need to be removed from the donor before respiration and circulation cease. Otherwise, these organs are not suitable, since damage to the organs occurs within a brief time after circulation of blood with oxygen stops.” [more]


Dr John B Shea

Dr John B Shea , retired diagnostic radiologist & Fellow of Royal College of Physicians & Surgeons of Canada, says: “Many physicians have serious and well-considered concerns about morality of human organ transplantation … the general public has not been properly informed about what really happens when organs are retrieved.” [more]


Bereaved mother

Bereaved mother (Bernice Jones) says: “ Brain death is not death” and “organ donation is very deceptive”. “Families are led to believe that their loved ones are dead, but in fact they are alive. You must be alive to be a vital organ donor.” [more]


Nurse Ellen B Linde

Nurse Ellen B Linde , senior graduate teaching assistant, University of Scranton, says: “Some, believing that removing vital organs is what kills the patient, view organ donation… as an act of killing… not all nurses are comfortable with a value system driven primarily by the needs of transplant recipients rather than by the needs of the potential donor.” [more]


Earl E. Appleby Jr

Earl E. Appleby Jr , Director, Citizens United Resisting Euthanasia, says: “Anyone unwise enough to have signed an organ donor card also has legitimate cause for concern. Would you trust a doctor who regards your body “not as an organism in need of healing but as a container of biological useful materials” … That’s exactly what organ donors do. ” [more]


Michael Potts

Michael Potts , medical ethicist, says: “Any action that directly causes the death of a patient, even if it is for the good of others, opposes the goal of medicine not to harm that individual patient… It is precisely whether transplantation kills the donor that is the key issue that cuts to the heart of the goals of medicine.” [more]

Legal and Medical Fiction

Doctor refutes “brain death” as a ‘construct’ to enable organ transplanting

Dr Doyen Nguyen says that “Brain death” is a construct for the purpose of organ transplantation… the primary purpose of which was “to define irreversible coma as a new criterion for death”. (Doyen Nguyen OP: a professor at the Pontifical University of St. Thomas Aquinas in Rome.) Dr Nguyen was speaking doing an interview with Italian magazine Radici Cristiane in Rome, May 2019.

“When a doctor declares a comatose patient (whose heart is beating, and whose skin is warm and pink) to be dead, that patient does not thereby become dead.”

Dr Doyen Nguyen speaking in Rome 2019

According to LifeSiteNews: Dr Nguyen says that an Ad Hoc Harvard Committee in 1968 redefined the term “brain death” to mean someone in an irreversible coma. Nguyen says this was done in order to serve the interests of the organ transplantation industry and to avoid public outcry that would have viewed transplant surgeons as organ-stealing killers.

“brain death” has been a medical fiction from its very inception.

Dr Nguyen says that the term “irreversible coma” itself ”indicates that the patient is alive, for the simple reason that only a living person can become comatose or remain comatose. In other words, it would be an OXYMORON to say that a CORPSE IS IN COMA!”.

Dr Nguyen says that “brain death” has been a medical fiction from its very inception, and that the real reason why the Harvard Committee redefined irreversible coma as death… is for a two-fold purpose: (i) to have fresh, viable organs more readily available for the transplantation enterprise, and (ii) at the same time, to avoid any public outcry… over organ-stealing.

‘It should be evident to readers by now that “brain death” is a medico-legal fiction, a social construct for utilitarian purposes. It does not take much imagination to figure out that the transplantation enterprise is a multi-billion dollar (or Euro) business. Even the most staunched defender of “brain death,” Bernat, had to admit (albeit very reluctantly) that the concept of “brain death” is incoherent; but, according to him, in the real world of public law and policy, we must compromise so that death can be declared and organs procured.’

Dr Doyen Nguyen's new book on Definitions of Death

‘It is not correct to say that “brain death” is universally accepted. As Brugger points out, doubt about “brain death” has become an international consensus, in the sense that quite a number scholars in medicine, philosophy, and bioethics from countries worldwide have recognized that the “brain death” paradigm is unsound.’

‘It would be more correct to say that “brain death” has been universally imposed by legislation in different countries. The materialistic, utilitarian mindset of a consumerist culture has led to the so-called worldwide acceptance of “brain death.” ’


Doyen Nguyen is also a lay Dominican and states that : it is not morally admissible to bring about the death of a human being, not even in order to delay the death of other persons. In a nutshell, it is not morally permissible to do evil to achieve a good.


Doyen Nguyen, M.D., S.T.L., is a physician specialized in hematopathology and a moral theologian. She is currently pursuing her doctorate in theology at the Pontifical University of St. Thomas Aquinas (Angelicum) in Rome. Dr Nguyen is the author of “The New Definitions of Death for Organ Donation”, Peter Lang AG, International Academic Publishers, Bern 2018

(From: “ ‘Brain death’ is a medical fiction invented to harvest organs from living people: expert”, by Stephen Kokx, LifeSiteNews, viewed 23 May 2019 at: https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/brain-death-is-a-medical-fiction-invented-to-harvest-organs-from-living-people-expert)

(See also Dr Nguyen’s paper on the determination of death: “A Holistic Understanding of Death: Ontological and Medical Considerations” viewed online at : https://www.diametros.iphils.uj.edu.pl/index.php/diametros/article/view/1175)

Dr Shewmon Radio Interview, 2003

An extract from a radio interview:

Wendy Carlisle (radio host): So is brain death the death of the person, in your opinion?
Alan Shewmon (guest): I used to think that it was. But in fact, during the 1980s and early 90s I read a number of articles and gave lectures supporting that idea, and since then I have had to change my opinion about it due to an accumulation of evidence to the contrary. …
Wendy Carlisle: I think you’ve actually called somewhere the notion of brain death a medical fiction.
Alan Shewmon: A legal fiction.
Wendy Carlisle: A legal fiction. What does that mean, then, in your opinion for the whole donor debate?
Alan Shewmon: I guess it’s also a medical fiction. You’re right.

Alan Shewmon
Professor of Neurology and Pediatrics,
University of California (Los Angeles) School of Medicine

(From “All In the Mind”, Radio National, Australian Broadcasting Corporation, Feb 2, 2003. Transcript viewed Dec 18, 2010 at: http://www.abc.net.au/rn/science/mind/s746719.htm )

Or go to http://www.abc.net.au/ then click on ABC Radio, then Radio National and finally click on “All In The Mind”.